已经决定了， 谢谢
要是为了儿子，就搏一下南洋吧，不然以后还得折腾一次。
是公民吧？南洋值得博一下，女儿小六升学有优惠，儿子又能借光入小学。
是的，南洋小学的女孩PSLE 250分就能进南洋女中了，别的小学的需要262分以上。
非常感谢你们这么快的回复
已经换了公民了
我觉得报莱小吧，能进一个算一个，万一南洋的抽不倒，老二一样要折腾一次，还把姐姐的机会给搭上了。
还有，孩子既然是公民，又住在一公里的范围，看今年小一报名的情况，明年调整的可能性很大，报上不是有人呼吁，让校友的孩子和弟妹继续享有优先报名权，但要以住家距离母校的远近作为录取依据。 我估计，等到你家老二报名的时候，进南洋的机会可能会比现在的大。
如果是两女儿，或两儿子，或大儿子，小女儿就不会有此纠结了
如果没有所谓的名校，就不会有此烦恼了，呵呵
通俗点说，这是个体的一个不可重复的概率计算。
选NY, 女儿50%,对儿子来说，并不是100%NY，而也是50%
选RG，女儿90%,对儿子来说，NY也是50%.
（不论学校及政策）
用物理的知识来说：
一种是串联，姐姐NY不成，后面串着的也不成，这条电路DOWN的机会就是50%;
一种是并联，姐姐NY不成，并着的弟弟本身自带50%的NY(假设几年后申请率不变，建议查一查这几年两所学校的申请率是否有显著规律）。
选RGS。政策的东西不好说，经常变来变去，先把女儿弄进去再说。万一儿子进了邻里小学，让他早点接触奥数，参加考GEP的补习班，小三时拼一拼GEP，换个好学校。
如果是我选：NY！
谢谢大家的意见，如果能说出选的理由就更好了
理由就一条：南洋是新加坡最好的小学！！
觉得如果选南洋，万一进不了，那么也肯定进不了莱佛士了。皮之不存毛将焉附？还能顾及到弟弟吗？
同意先搞定姐姐的学校。
嗯， 住那一带的听说若是没抽上， 他们会选Bukit Timah Primary school，这虽说是一个普通小学，但每年都有Nanyang, RGS 没抽上的孩子拼GEP,所以每年几十个上GEP,远远多余其他邻里小学。
几十个有点夸张了吧，南洋小学每年考上GEP的人数也不过如此。
而且这间小学的PSLE成绩也很普通，这样的学校应该不会出如此多的GEP学生。
具体情况我不是特别了解，但我同事的孩子就在那里上学，从来也没听她说过此事。我刚刚问了同事，答曰：没听说过啊。
30多个，很有可能是GEP过第一轮的人数。
那小学很多马来老师和马来孩子。
我女儿小一期末，我拿成绩帮她转校， 申请了南小， 莱小，培华等等近十所小学， 只这间Bukit Timah Primary school收了。
上课一个月了， 书本校服都买好了， 培华才来通知。于是又换去了培华。
嗯，忘记解释PSLE成绩和GEP的关系了。
一般而言，考进GEP远远比在PSLE中考出好成绩更难。如果一间小学有这么多人考上GEP, 证明那里还有很多学习能力很强但没考上GEP的孩子，这些孩子一定会在PSLE中考取好成绩。
反之亦然。。。
不是这个,应该是培华.每年可以上10多个GEP, 比儒廊还好. 算是非GEP学校中最多的了.
而且,培华考上GEP的很容易就可以报上南洋小学, 因为根据教育部GEP录取政策, 南洋会优先录取来自培华的学生.
嗯， 我也是听邻居说的（新加坡本地人，她的孩子在Bukit Timah Primary, 并没考上GEP），数据可能并不准确。
GEP真的主要靠家长和孩子，自己的同部门同事和同小区的孩子（家长都是中国来的）考上GEP的应该有个小10个了，都是从邻里小学考上的，家长的作用还是很重要的。当然孩子资质也不能太差，至少要早慧，间接也说明在新GEP并不是可望不可即的，考上了也别以为就是什么天才。当然， 在我眼里，每个孩子都是gifted ：-）。
要我选莱小，首先机会大，如果姐弟俩年龄相差超过两岁，姐姐一年级后转校南洋，应该比较容易
选南洋小学,
女孩子将来上南洋女中,可以比录取分数线少10分,
可是上莱小, 将来上莱佛士女中,完全没有扣分优待
同学你好，请告知下上哪边能查什么小学上什么中学有分数优惠？不甚感激。。
我来越俎代庖一下～～～
1. 中小学及初院附属关系表：
Primary
Secondary
Junior College
Anglo-Chinese School (Junior)Anglo-Chinese School (Barker Road),
Anglo-Chinese School (Independent)Anglo-Chinese Junior College Anglo-Chinese School (Primary)Anglo-Chinese School (Barker Road),
Anglo-Chinese School (Independent)Anglo-Chinese Junior College Canossa Convent Primary SchoolSt. Anthony’s Canossian Secondary SchoolCatholic Junior College Catholic High SchoolCatholic High School Catholic Junior College CHIJ (Katong) PrimaryCHIJ Katong ConventCatholic Junior College CHIJ (Kellock)CHIJ St. Theresa’s ConventCatholic Junior College CHIJ Our Lady of Good CounselCHIJ St. Joseph’s ConventCatholic Junior College CHIJ Our Lady of the NativityCHIJ St. Joseph’s ConventCatholic Junior College CHIJ Our Lady Queen of PeaceCHIJ St. Theresa’s ConventCatholic Junior College CHIJ Primary (Toa Payoh)CHIJ Secondary (Toa Payoh)Catholic Junior College CHIJ St. Nicholas Girls’ SchoolCHIJ St. Nicholas Girls’ SchoolCatholic Junior College De La Salle SchoolSt. Joseph’s Institution, St. Patrick’s SchoolCatholic Junior College Fairfield Methodist School (Primary)Fairfield Methodist School (Secondary)Anglo-Chinese Junior College Geylang Methodist School (Primary)Geylang Methodist School (Secondary)Anglo-Chinese Junior College Holy Innocents’ Primary SchoolHoly Innocents’ High SchoolCatholic Junior College Kuo Chuan Presbyterian Primary SchoolKuo Chuan Presbyterian Secondary School St. Andrew’s Junior CollegeMaha Bodhi SchoolManjusri Secondary School
Maris Stella High SchoolMaris Stella High School Catholic Junior College Mee Toh SchoolManjusri Secondary School
Methodist Girls’ School (Primary)Methodist Girls’ School (Secondary)Anglo-Chinese Junior College Montfort Junior SchoolMontfort Secondary School Catholic Junior College Nanyang Primary School Nanyang Girls’ High School
Ngee Ann Primary School Ngee Ann Secondary School
Paya Lebar Methodist Girls’ School (Primary)Paya Lebar Methodist Girls’ School (Secondary)Anglo-Chinese Junior College Singapore Chinese Girls’ Primary SchoolSingapore Chinese Girls’ School
St. Andrew’s Junior SchoolSt. Andrew’s Secondary SchoolSt. Andrew’s Junior CollegeSt. Anthony’s Canossian Primary SchoolSt. Anthony’s Canossian Secondary SchoolCatholic Junior College St. Anthony’s Primary SchoolSt. Joseph’s Institution, St. Patrick’s SchoolCatholic Junior College St. Gabriel’s Primary SchoolSt. Gabriel’s Secondary SchoolCatholic Junior College St. Hilda’s Primary SchoolSt. Hilda’s Secondary SchoolSt. Andrew’s Junior CollegeSt. Joseph’s Institution JuniorSt. Joseph’s Institution, St. Patrick’s SchoolCatholic Junior College St. Margaret’s Primary SchoolSt. Margaret’s Secondary SchoolSt. Andrew’s Junior CollegeSt. Stephen’s SchoolSt. Joseph’s Institution, St. Patrick’s SchoolCatholic Junior College
Anglican High School St. Andrew’s Junior College
Assumption English School Catholic Junior College
Christ Church Secondary School St. Andrew’s Junior College
Chung Cheng High School (Main)Nanyang Junior College
Chung Cheng High School (Yishun)Nanyang Junior College
Hai Sing Catholic School Catholic Junior College
Hwa Chong InstitutionHwa Chong Institution
Presbyterian High School St. Andrew’s Junior College
Raffles Girls’ School (Secondary)Raffles Institution
JJ你好，请问，有此附属关系的，都有分数优惠么？所有优惠幅度，都一致么？谢谢你
2.
2011年中学录取分数线（Affilation-Lower 那一栏就是优惠后的分数线）：
PSLE Aggregate Range (2012 Intake)
Non-AffiliationAffiliationS/NName of SchoolLowerUpper Mean MedianLowerUpper Mean Median NUS High School of Mathematics & Science——– School of Science & Technology, Singaore——– Singapore Sport School——–1Nanyang Gils’ High School2622772672662502722582572Raffles Girls’ School (Secondary School)261283266265—-3Raffles Institution261273265264—-4Hwa Chong Institution258274262261—-5Cedar Girls’ Secondary School (IP)258265260260—-6National Junior College258269260259—-7Dunman High School256273260259—-8Victory School (IP)255266257257—-9River Valley High School254270258257—-10Methodist Gils’ School (Secondary)25026325425422026824224311Cedar Girls’ Secondary School (O-level)249271253253—-12Chij St. Nicholas Gils’ School24926825325221126523623713Singapore Chinese Girls’ School24826825225222027124024114Catholic High School24826425225223025824324215Anglo-Chinese School (Independent)24726725225223526624624616Victory School (O-Level)247259251251—-17Anderson Secondary School245264250248—-18Bukit Panjang Govt. High School244266248247—-19Nan Hua High School243269248247—-20Anglican High School243262248247—-21Crescent Gils’ School243260247246—-22St. Joseph’s Institution24227024624523826524524423Chij Secondary School (Toa Payoh)24124824324320025822622624St. Margaret’s Secondary School24024924224118824821521425Chung Cheng High School (main)237258242241—-26Nan Chiau High School236262242241—-27Commonwealth Secondary School236261240239—-28Xingmin Secondary School235253241240—-29Tangjong Katong Girls’ School235255240240—-30Fairfield Methodist Secondary School23524923923920026322422531Swiss Cottage Secondary School235263238238—-32Tanjong Katong Secondary School233256238237—-33Ngee Ann Secondary School23325523823721023421921834Paya Lebar Methodist Girls’ School (Secondary)23324823723618825122022135Yishun Town Secondary School232257239239—-36Chung Cheng High School (Yishun)232253237236—-37Zhonghua Secondary School232259236235—-38Maris Stella High School23225123623622625123323139St. Andrew’s Secondary School23124523523518824021421440Kranji Secondary School230248234233—-41Temasek Secondary School230260233232—-42Dunman Secondary School229257233232—-43Clementi Town Secondary School229247232232—-44Presbyterian High School229254232231—-45Fuhua Secondary School228243232231—-46St. Hilda’s Secondary School22824123122918823921020847Riverside Secondary School227259233231—-48Chij St. Joseph’s Convent22725323123020023321421449Ang Mo Kio Secondary School226245229228—-50St. Anthony’s Canossian Secondary School22623922922818823020920851Kuo Chuan Presbyterian Secondary School22624122822818824321021052Jurong Secondary School225250230228—-53Hai Sing Catholic School225243228227—-54Chij St. Theresa’s’ Convent22424023123120023521721755Gan Eng Seng School224252229228—-56Chij Katong Convent22423922822720023321621557Bowen Secondary School223244228227—-58West Spring Secondary School222240227227—-59Evergreen Secondary School222248226225—-60Bukit Batok Secondary School222240226225—-61St. Patrick’s School22123622522518823720820762Pasir Ris Secondary School221245224224—-63Mayflower Secondary School220244224223—-64Hua Yi secondary School220240224223—-65Unity Secondary School219246224223—-66Holy Innocents’ High School21923322322218925220720767Ahmad Ibrahim Secondary School217237222221—-68Pasir Ris Crest Secondary School218233222221—-69Geylang Methodist School (secondary)21723922222219523621121170Bedok View Secondary School217231222221—-71Chua Chu Kang Secondary School217233220219—-72Beatty Secondary School216244221220—-73St. Gabriel’s Secondary School21623522122118823420720774Compassval Secondary School215240222221—-75Woodlands Ring Secondary School215242221220—-76Yuan Ching Secondary School214228218218—-77Deyi Secondary School213233217216—-78Bedok South Secondary School213228217216—-79Edgrefield Secondary School212243220219—-80Orchid Park Secondary School212230217216—-81Queensway Secondary School212230217216—-82Zhenghua Secondary School 212237216215—-83Westwood Secondary School210251216215—-84Woodgrove Secondary School210238215214—-85Coral Secondary School210251215214—-86Peirce Secondary School209232214213—-87East Spring Secondary School208244214213—-88Yishun Secondary School208231214214—-89North Vista Secondary School207237213211—-90Greenridge Secondary School207221210210—-91Dunearnn Secondary School206234212211—-92Montfort Secondary School20622421221118823220320393Admiralty Secondary School206225211210—-94Bedok Green Secondary School205247210209—-95Jurongville Secondary School205234210209—-96Bukit View Secondary School204242211210—-97Tampines Secondary School204227209207—-98Canberra Secondary School203234208207—-99New Town Secondary School202230210208—-100Hougang Secondary School202228209207—-101Pei Hwa Secondary School202229209206—-102Damai Secondary School202228208207—-103Queenstown Secondary School201226209208—-104Christ Church Secondary School201229208207—-105Hillgrove Secondary School201224205204—-106Manjusri Secondary School200232209208188220203203107Junyuan Secondary School200228207205—-108Naval Base Secondary School200231206205—-109Seng Kang Secondary School196230203201—-110Guangyang Secondary School195223203202—-111Greendale Secondary School195230202200—-112Jurong West Secondary School193229203201—-113Greenview secondary School193224201199—-114Si Ling Secondary School190221204201—-115Kent Ridge Secondary School190226202200—-116Marsling Secondary School190224201199—-117Punggol Secondary School190220197194—-118Anglo-Chinese School (Barker)—-189249218217119Balestier Hill Secondary School189247208207—-120Chestnut Drive Secondary School189267206203—-121First Toa Payoh Secondary School189231204200—-122BedokTown Secondary School188237204201—-123Broadrick Secondary School188244204201—-124Peicai Secondary School188231204202—-125Assumption English School188254203200—-126Benemeer Secondary School188231203202—-127Yusof Ishak Secondary School188250203199—-128Chong Boon Secondary School188220202203—-129Pioneer Secondary School188250202198—-130Teck Whye Secondary School189227201200—-131Bartley Secondary School188249201200—-132Clementi Woods Secondary School188236201200—-133Henderson Secondary School188257201197—-134McPherson Secondary School188232201200—-135Serangoon Garden Secondary School188265201199—-136Tanglin Secondary School188256201198—-137Whitley Secondary School188243201200—-138Regent Secondary School189227200200—-139Bedok North Secondary School188248200197—-140Bukit Merah Secondary School188246200198—-141Juying Secondary School188236200195—-142North View Secondary School188227200198—-143Northbrooks Secondary School188232200198—-144Outram Secondary School188223200199—-145Ping Yi Secondary School188224200199—-146Siglap Secondary School188224200200—-147Yio Chu Kang Secondary School188223200200—-148Yuhua Secondary School188228200198—-149Bishan Park Secondary School188236199198—-150Boonlay Secondary School188227199199—-151Hong Kah Secondary School188242199198—-152Shuqun Secondary School188224199198—-153Yuying Secondary School188232199197—-154Chai Chee Secondary School188231198197—-155Changkat Changi Secondary School188231198197—-156East View Secondary School188255198196—-157Fajar Secondary School188230198197—-158Fuchun Secondary School188223198199—-159Loyang Secondary School188237198195—-160Sembawang Secondary School188227198198—-161Serangoon Secondary School188232198194—-162Woodlands secondary School188245198196—-163Northland Secondary School188220197196—-164Springfield Secondary School188231197196—-165Assumption Pathway School——–166Northlight School——–167Telok Kurau Secondary School——–
注：DSA学生的PSLE成绩不在统计之列。
都有优惠，但各自的标准不同。详情见上。
谢谢姐姐。
几个问题，
1. 上面有很多188. 188是个什么概念？ 白菜分数么？是说少过188没学校上么？
2. 有些学校lower 188, upper265, e.g. below. 这是啥么情况？ 265不是能上很好的学校了么？
3. 进了某个中学后，中学内班级是按psle分班的么？
再次拜谢
135Serangoon Garden Secondary School188265
1. 上面有很多188. 188是个什么概念？ 白菜分数么？是说少过188没学校上么？
188是快捷课程(Express)的最低分数线，再低的还有普通学术（Normal Academic)和普通工艺（Normal Technical)，后二者的最低录取分数是159和119。
2. 有些学校lower 188, upper265, e.g. below. 这是啥么情况？ 265不是能上很好的学校了么？
一部分原因是本地有些家长比较在乎的是学校离家的距离，而不是学校的名声。还有一个原因是有些孩子报志愿的时候填错了 。。。
3. 进了某个中学后，中学内班级是按psle分班的么？
有些是，有些不是。通常到了中三的时候还要按成绩再分一次。
p.s. 我不是姐姐。
谢谢你指点。不好意思，看你ID starts with JJ. 我就姐姐的叫顺上了。。
哈哈，在网上性别不重要。
那个谁不是说嘛：雄兔脚扑朔，雌兔眼迷离。双兔傍地走，安能辨我是雄雌？
恩恩，版版真豁达。快快赐我一个pv宝典吧
这位哥哥，请问您这里列出的都算是好的小学么？
太好笑了！让我想起以前我女儿喜欢看的一个动画片《红猫蓝兔七侠传》。
这应该是两个互斥不独立事件，不能用（1-P)(1-P). 所以，但从概率方面考虑，还是觉得选R大．
你可以等到最后一天下午看南洋的报名情况再做决定。
今年莱小2C阶段还有56个位，参考往年报名情况，1公里之内新公民报名肯定能上。南洋的话多半要抽签但不知道概率是多少。
如果是我的话我会选莱小。为什么要因为弟弟的原因而让姐姐去冒险？这个对姐姐来说不公平。
是的，谢谢你的回复，莱小也是好学校，不会为了弟弟，就让姐姐去冒险， 能进我们肯定就求稳了，除非两边抽签的成功率相差不是很大，那样也许就博下了
1. 如果姐报南洋：
姐弟同时入南洋的几率：60% X 100% = 60%
姐弟都入不了南洋的几率：40% X 40% = 16%
姐弟至少有一个入南洋的几率：100% – 16% = 84%
2. 如果姐报莱小：
姐弟同时入名校的几率：90% X 60% = 54%
姐弟都入不了名校的几率：10% X 40% = 4%
姐弟至少有一个入名校的几率：100 – 4% = 96%
从概率上看，姐姐报莱小比报南洋好，姐弟至少有一个入名校的成功率比较高，其中姐姐入名校几率为90%，弟弟为60%。如果追求两个都上名校的机会，那就姐姐报南洋吧，成功率比报莱小多6%，但两个都失败的几率也增加了12%，且其中姐姐入名校的几率下降为60%，弟弟入名校的机会增加为60% X 100% + 40% X 60% = 84%，也就是所谓牺牲姐姐成全弟弟了。
高人, 赞一个!
谢谢分析，如果莱小稳进或两者机率差很大， 就不会为了弟弟牺牲掉姐姐的， 两年后也不知道会有什么变化呢，姐姐南洋不成功， 我们会住在A处，这样两年后弟弟会不会报南洋也会很纠结的， 毕竟两个孩子上学距离隔那么远，其实姐姐这次也决定了弟弟要不要读南洋，看这两天两所学校具体的情况，我们会最终做决定，再次感谢！
粗粗的看了一下啊，好像名校都在中西部啊，这让住在东部的同学情何以堪，孩子们爬山涉水舍近求远值得吗，太辛苦啦。
东部有几间，但是不出彩啊。
姐姐今年进莱小。弟弟两年后抽签南洋。南洋进不去的话去BUKIT TIMAH PRIMARY SCHOOL. 这所学校属于中等偏上的学校，离你的B家应该也不算太远。
现在外面一直争论小一入学报名的问题尤其是父母是曾经校友而带来的优先权问题。搞不好这两年政策会有所改变，减少这方面的名额。这样的话你儿子两年后报名的时候在2C阶段学额会多一些。
莱小很好，你不会后悔的。
谢谢回复， 呵呵， 没有一劳永逸的事情， 眼前的先拿吧
BUKIT TIMAH小学 在那个区挺冷门的，估计是其他的周围学校都太突出了
美女，最后选择了哪里，用抽签吗